AAA Class Action Lawsuits: UIM Settlement, Antitrust, and Data Breach

There are three active AAA class action lawsuits worth knowing about, and they involve two different organizations that share the initials. The largest is Smith v. Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club, a $4.15 million settlement over underinsured motorist coverage sold to New Mexico drivers by the auto club insurer. A second case, Stephens v. American Arbitration Association, accuses the country’s dominant consumer arbitration provider of running an illegal monopoly. A third targets AAA Northeast’s Driver Training School over a data breach affecting more than 25,000 students. Which one applies to you depends on whether you held an auto policy, signed an arbitration agreement, or took a driving course.

Smith v. AAA: The New Mexico Underinsured Motorist Settlement

This is the case most people are searching for. Filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico as Case No. 1:22-cv-00447-WJ-JMR, the lawsuit alleged that AAA wrongfully reduced underinsured motorist (UIM) claim payments by subtracting whatever the at-fault driver’s insurer had already paid, and that AAA did not adequately warn policyholders this would happen. For a customer carrying only state-minimum coverage, the offset could wipe out UIM benefits almost entirely.

AAA denies wrongdoing. The parties agreed to a $4.15 million settlement, which received preliminary court approval. The final fairness hearing was scheduled for on or after May 13, 2026.

Who Is Covered

The class is limited to New Mexico policyholders and covers January 1, 2010 through May 4, 2022. It splits into two groups:

  • Offset subclass: people who filed a UIM claim with AAA during the class period and had it reduced by the at-fault driver’s insurance payment.
  • General class: anyone who bought a New Mexico auto policy from AAA that included UM/UIM coverage during that period, whether or not they filed a claim.

Claims involving an uninsured driver — one with no liability insurance at all — are not part of the offset subclass.

What Members Receive

Offset subclass members can receive up to $25,000 each. If valid claims exceed the portion of the fund set aside for the subclass, payments will be reduced proportionally.

General class members are eligible for a partial refund of the UM/UIM premiums they paid during the class period. The exact amount depends on premiums paid, administration costs, and other factors. General class members do not need to file anything; qualifying checks are mailed automatically.

Class counsel requested $1,383,195 in fees and up to $5,000 in costs, paid from the settlement fund before class distributions.

Deadlines and Status

The claim form deadline for offset subclass members was April 29, 2026. The deadline to opt out or object was March 30, 2026. Payments will not go out until the court grants final approval and any appeals are resolved.

The settlement administrator can be reached at 1-877-268-1879 or by mail at Smith v. AAA, PO Box 5339, Portland, OR 97208-5339. The official website is aaauimsettlement.com.

Similar UIM Settlements Against Other Insurers

If you held New Mexico auto coverage through another company during roughly the same period, you may be covered by a parallel case. The same offset issue has produced settlements or pending settlements against:

  • Nationwide: $2.65 million settlement covering UIM claims offset between October 1, 2010 and March 31, 2022. No admission of wrongdoing.
  • State Farm: Schwartz v. State Farm, Case No. 1:18-cv-00328-KWR-SCY (D.N.M.), addressing UIM coverage sold January 1, 2010 through December 31, 2021. Settlement pending court approval.
  • Progressive: Peck v. Progressive, challenging premiums charged for stacked UM/UIM coverage on single-vehicle policies, with a class period from January 2009 through April 2025. Final approval hearing scheduled for February 2026.

Stephens v. American Arbitration Association: The Antitrust Case

This case involves a different organization that also goes by AAA — the American Arbitration Association, which runs private arbitrations that consumers are often forced into by fine print in cellphone, credit, and payment-app contracts. It is not related to the auto club.

Filed in May 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona as Stephens v. American Arbitration Association, Inc., Case No. 2:25-cv-01650-JJT, the proposed class action alleges the AAA has built an illegal monopoly over consumer arbitration in the United States. The named plaintiffs are Stephanie Stephens, Joelle Nole, William Hilton, and Eugenie Balogun.

What the Lawsuit Alleges

According to the complaint, the AAA has handled roughly 94% of all private consumer arbitrations filed in the past seven years. JAMS, the next largest provider, holds about 5%. NAM accounts for 0.0003%. Plaintiffs say the AAA maintains this position by supplying companies with sample arbitration clauses that designate the AAA as the sole forum, and by capping arbitrator pay at $300 per hour for consumer cases — a rate the complaint says both discourages qualified arbitrators from taking consumer work and blocks competing providers from entering the market.

Plaintiffs cite outcome data to argue the process favors businesses: consumers lose 73% of AAA arbitrations nationally, compared with 60% at JAMS. The complaint brings claims under Section 2 of the Sherman Act and under state antitrust and consumer protection laws in Arizona, West Virginia, North Carolina, and Washington. The plaintiffs are not asking the court to reopen any individual arbitration; they describe the case as being “purely about choice.”

Current Status

On March 31, 2026, Judge John J. Tuchi denied the AAA’s motion to dismiss, including its argument that arbitral immunity barred the case. The court found the plaintiffs had adequately alleged monopoly power and that the challenged conduct was corporate and structural, not the handling of any specific arbitration. The AAA filed its answer in April 2026, and a scheduling order followed in early June 2026. The case is in discovery. No class has been certified.

AAA Northeast Driver Training School Data Breach

In March 2026, AAA Northeast disclosed that an unauthorized third party had accessed a software vendor’s system the previous December. The breach exposed personal information for 25,247 driver training students, including names, contact information, dates of birth, and driver’s license or permit numbers. AAA Northeast said the incident was limited to the vendor’s system and did not reach other AAA driving school operations or corporate data.

A class action followed the notification letters. The specific plaintiff, court, and case number have not been publicly reported in available sources as of mid-2026. If you received a notice from AAA Northeast about this incident, keep it — you will likely need it to participate.

Older AAA Cases That Are Already Closed

Two earlier cases sometimes surface in searches but are no longer active. Gee et al., filed in 2015 in the Southern District of California (Case No. 15-cv-0246), alleged AAA failed to properly disclose automatic renewal terms. It was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice in March 2015. Thomas v. Automobile Club of Southern California, an employment case over wage statements, overtime, rest breaks, and commission plans, received final settlement approval in February 2020, and funds have been distributed. The settlement amount was not publicly disclosed.