Flamethrowers are legal in war, but only within tight limits. International humanitarian law does not ban them outright. Protocol III of the 1980 Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons regulates them as incendiary weapons, forbidding any use against civilians and sharply restricting use anywhere near them. In practice, the conditions are demanding enough that lawful use is narrow, which is one reason most major militaries have moved on from these weapons.
The Treaty That Governs Flamethrowers
The controlling instrument is Protocol III to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, adopted in 1980. It defines an “incendiary weapon” as any weapon primarily designed to set fire to objects or cause burn injuries through flame, heat, or a chemical reaction, and it names flamethrowers as an example.1United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs (UNODA). Protocol on Prohibitions or Restrictions on the Use of Incendiary Weapons (Protocol III)
Article 2 sets out a tiered scheme:
- Incendiary weapons can never be used against civilian populations, individual civilians, or civilian objects. No exceptions.
- Air-delivered incendiary weapons cannot be used against any military objective located within a concentration of civilians.
- Ground-delivered incendiary weapons, the category that includes flamethrowers, may be used against a military objective near civilians only if that objective is clearly separated from the civilian population and the operator takes all feasible precautions to limit the fire’s effects to the target and minimize civilian harm.
- Forests and other plant cover cannot be set alight unless they are being used to conceal combatants or are themselves military objectives.
The split between air-delivered and ground-delivered matters. Air-dropped incendiaries are banned outright in populated areas; a flamethrower gets a narrow exception if the target is physically separated from civilians.1United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs (UNODA). Protocol on Prohibitions or Restrictions on the Use of Incendiary Weapons (Protocol III)
The General Rules That Also Apply
Protocol III sits on top of three principles of international humanitarian law that apply to every weapon in a conflict.
Distinction requires combatants to separate military targets from civilians, and it prohibits weapons that by their nature strike both indiscriminately.2International Committee of the Red Cross. Weapons Flamethrowers can be aimed, so they are not banned on this ground alone, but fire spreads in ways that make the principle harder to satisfy.
Proportionality prohibits attacks where expected civilian harm would be excessive compared to the concrete military advantage. A flamethrower attack on a legitimate bunker surrounded by homes can easily fail this test even if the bunker itself is a valid target.
Unnecessary suffering bars weapons designed to cause pain beyond what is needed to disable a combatant. Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions states: “It is prohibited to employ weapons, projectiles and material and methods of warfare of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering.”3International Committee of the Red Cross. Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, 1977 – Article 35 Flamethrowers cause severe burns, but states chose to regulate them rather than treat them as inherently excessive.
When Flamethrower Use Is Actually Lawful
Pulling the rules together, a military force can lawfully use a flamethrower against a legitimate military objective when civilians are neither present nor at risk. An isolated bunker in open terrain, or a weapons cache far from any civilian population, is the kind of scenario Protocol III leaves room for. The attack still has to satisfy proportionality, and the commander must take feasible precautions to keep the fire from spreading beyond the target.1United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs (UNODA). Protocol on Prohibitions or Restrictions on the Use of Incendiary Weapons (Protocol III)
The problems start anywhere near civilian areas. The “clearly separated” standard is demanding, and fire is difficult to control. In urban combat, where fighters operate among civilian populations, scenarios that satisfy every requirement are rare.
The “Primarily Designed” Gap
Protocol III has a limit that humanitarian organizations have criticized for decades. The definition covers only munitions “primarily designed” to set fires or cause burns. It expressly excludes munitions with incidental incendiary effects, such as illumination rounds, tracers, and smoke systems, and combined-effects munitions like armor-piercing or explosive rounds where burning is secondary to penetration or blast.4International Committee of the Red Cross. CCW Protocol III Prohibiting Incendiary Weapons, 1980 – Article 1
White phosphorus is the most prominent example. It causes devastating burns on skin contact, but because it is often classified as a smoke or illumination round rather than a weapon “primarily designed” to burn, it can fall outside Protocol III’s restrictions. Whether a weapon qualifies as incendiary depends on how it is categorized, not on what it does to people on the receiving end.
Which Countries Are Bound
Protocol III binds only countries that have formally ratified or acceded to it. As of March 2026, 116 countries are parties, including the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia, China, Germany, India, and Japan.5United Nations Treaty Collection. CCW and Protocol – United Nations Treaty Collection The United States ratified in January 2009, nearly three decades after the treaty opened.6U.S. Department of State. U.S. Joins Four Law of War Treaties
Countries outside Protocol III are not directly bound by its specific restrictions, but the underlying rules against targeting civilians and inflicting unnecessary suffering exist independently as customary international law and apply to every party in an armed conflict.
Why Modern Militaries Rarely Use Them
The legal framework matters even though the classic backpack flamethrower has largely disappeared from active service. The United States retired flamethrowers in 1978, before it ever ratified Protocol III. The M9, the last model in U.S. inventory, was replaced by the M202 FLASH, a rocket-based incendiary system with greater range and precision. The change was driven by practical reality more than by law: fuel tanks made operators obvious targets, range was short, and other weapons could do the same work more safely.
Retirement of the traditional flamethrower did not end the legal questions. Modern incendiary systems still fall under Protocol III for the countries bound by it. The delivery method changed; the rules did not.
A Note on Civilian Ownership
Protocol III governs armed conflict, not domestic ownership. In the United States, flamethrowers are not classified as firearms under the National Firearms Act, and no federal law regulates them. Maryland bans civilian ownership; California requires a permit; other states allow them. The wartime restrictions discussed above have no bearing on that separate question.