BEPS Action 7: Dependent Agents, Anti-Fragmentation, and the MLI

BEPS Action 7 is the OECD’s 2015 rewrite of the permanent establishment rules, and it lowers the threshold at which a foreign company becomes taxable in a country where it does business. The changes were folded into the 2017 update of the OECD Model Tax Convention1OECD. 2017 Update to the OECD Model Tax Convention and pushed into bilateral treaties through the Multilateral Instrument. In practice, sales representatives who negotiate but don’t sign, warehouses that support online retail, businesses split across related entities, and construction projects broken into short contracts are all more likely to create a taxable presence than they were under the old rules.

The New Dependent Agent Test

The biggest substantive change targets the arrangement where a local representative does everything short of putting pen to paper. Under the previous standard, a foreign company avoided a permanent establishment as long as final contract signature happened at headquarters overseas, even if the local agent had negotiated every meaningful term.

The revised rule, reflected in MLI Article 12, creates a permanent establishment when a person habitually plays the “principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded without material modification by the enterprise.”2OECD. Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent BEPS – Article 12 The signature no longer controls. A person is treated as playing the principal role if their activities directly resulted in the contract or represented the majority of the effort behind it.

The rule is aimed squarely at commissionnaire arrangements, where a local entity sells goods in its own name for a foreign parent. The old defense was that the commissionnaire was formally independent. Under the new test, what matters is the substance of the selling activity, not the label on the paperwork.

When an Agent Is No Longer “Independent”

An agent cannot claim independent status if they work exclusively or almost exclusively for one enterprise or a group of closely related enterprises. Two enterprises are considered closely related where one holds more than 50 percent of the beneficial interest or voting power in the other, or where both are under common control.3OECD. The 2025 Update to the OECD Model Tax Convention Relabeling a captive sales team as an “independent broker” no longer works if that team has no other real clients.

Warehouses, Fulfillment Centers, and the “Preparatory or Auxiliary” Exception

The OECD Model has long carved out activities that do not create a permanent establishment on their own: storing goods, maintaining stock for processing by another party, purchasing supplies, or collecting information. Action 7 attached a condition. Those activities now qualify for the exception only if they are genuinely preparatory or auxiliary to the enterprise’s core business.4OECD. Preventing the Artificial Avoidance of Permanent Establishment Status, Action 7 – 2015 Final Report

This reshapes the calculus for online retail. A digital seller whose whole value proposition is fast local delivery cannot credibly say a large fulfillment center in the country is merely auxiliary. The warehouse is the business. The test is functional: is the activity so far from the profit-making core that taxing it would be unreasonable? A small foreign office collecting market data for a pharmaceutical company probably still qualifies. A distribution hub moving thousands of shipments a day to local customers probably does not.

Failing the auxiliary test means the foreign company becomes taxable on the share of its global profits attributable to that local facility. Companies that assumed the old exemption still applied can face back-tax assessments plus interest and penalties.

The Anti-Fragmentation Rule

A related avoidance strategy involved slicing a cohesive business into small pieces spread across separate legal entities in the same country. Each piece could claim, in isolation, that its activity was preparatory or auxiliary. Together they ran a functional business.

Article 5(4.1) of the revised Model, implemented through MLI Article 13, closes that path. Tax authorities now evaluate the combined activities of an enterprise and its closely related entities in a country. If those activities are complementary functions that form part of a cohesive business operation, the preparatory-or-auxiliary exception is denied to all of them.5OECD. Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent BEPS – Article 13 One entity storing goods while a related entity in the same country sells them is a single selling-and-delivery operation for treaty purposes, even if the legal structure says otherwise. Auditors look through the entity chart to the economic reality of the revenue stream.

Contract Splitting on Construction Projects

Most treaties create a permanent establishment for construction or installation projects that last beyond a set period, usually twelve months. The old workaround was to split a long project into shorter contracts, each held by a different group affiliate, so no single contract broke the threshold.

MLI Article 14 aggregates the time. Where an enterprise conducts construction or similar activities at a site for more than 30 days, and a closely related enterprise conducts connected activities at the same site during a different period also exceeding 30 days, those periods are added together for the treaty threshold.6OECD. Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent BEPS – Article 14 Rotating affiliates through a long-running site no longer resets the clock. The 30-day minimum keeps brief site visits out of the calculation.

How Much Profit Gets Taxed Once a PE Exists

Establishing that a permanent establishment exists is one question. The dollar figure is another. The OECD treats a PE as a “functionally separate entity” that deals with the rest of the enterprise at arm’s length.7OECD. Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments The profits attributed to the PE are what it would have earned as an independent company doing the same work, using the same assets, and bearing the same risks.

The analysis borrows from transfer pricing. Authorities look at what functions the PE performs, what assets it uses, and what risks it carries. A warehouse that only stores and ships earns a modest logistics-style return. A local sales team that finds customers, sets pricing, and manages accounts earns a larger share because it does more of the revenue-driving work. Home-country and host-country tax authorities often disagree about how much value the local operations really create, which is where disputes start.

When These Rules Actually Apply: The MLI Opt-In System

Action 7’s PE changes are not automatic. They enter a bilateral treaty only when both countries adopt the same MLI provisions with respect to that treaty. The Multilateral Convention was designed precisely to skip the impossible task of renegotiating thousands of bilateral treaties one at a time,8OECD. BEPS Multilateral Instrument and as of the most recent OECD data 107 jurisdictions have signed or become parties.9OECD. Signatories and Parties (BEPS MLI Positions)

The PE articles are not part of the mandatory minimum standards, so each country picks and chooses:

  • Article 12 (dependent agent and commissionnaire): adopt or reserve out entirely.
  • Article 13 (preparatory or auxiliary activities and anti-fragmentation): choose between two options, adopt or reject the anti-fragmentation rule, or decline the article.
  • Article 14 (contract splitting): adopt in full, reject, or adopt with a carve-out for natural resource exploration.
  • Article 15 (closely related enterprises): accept or reject the definition used across the other PE articles.

Because both treaty partners have to opt into the same provision, a multinational operating in twenty countries may find its treaty relationships updated in some pairs and untouched in others. Tracking the MLI position of every jurisdiction where the group operates is the only way to know which rules apply where.

The United States Has Not Signed

The United States is not a party to the MLI and has not indicated any intention to become one.8OECD. BEPS Multilateral Instrument The Congressional Research Service has noted that the United States has taken no specific action to implement the Action 7 recommendations.10Library of Congress. Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS): OECD/G20 Tax Proposals The 2016 U.S. Model Income Tax Convention still uses the older dependent agent formulation, requiring that the agent “habitually exercises” authority to conclude contracts binding on the enterprise, rather than the OECD’s broader “principal role” test.11U.S. Department of the Treasury. United States Model Income Tax Convention 2016 A local salesperson who negotiates all the terms without formal signing authority may create a PE under the OECD version and not under the U.S. version.

U.S. domestic law is a separate track. Under IRC Section 882, a foreign corporation engaged in a U.S. trade or business is taxed on income effectively connected with that business.12Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 882 – Tax on Income of Foreign Corporations Connected With United States Business A treaty can raise that threshold to a permanent establishment, meaning the company owes U.S. tax only if a PE exists under the treaty.

U.S. Disclosure and the Statute-of-Limitations Trap

A foreign company relying on a treaty to say it has no U.S. permanent establishment has to say so on the record. Under IRC Section 6114, any taxpayer taking a position that a U.S. treaty overrides domestic tax law must disclose that position on its return.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6114 – Treaty-Based Return Positions The IRS requires this on Form 8833, attached to the return (typically Form 1120-F for foreign corporations), with a separate form for each position each year.14Internal Revenue Service. Form 8833, Treaty-Based Return Position Disclosure Under Section 6114 or 7701(b)

Skipping the disclosure carries a penalty of $1,000 per position for most taxpayers and $10,000 per position for C corporations.15Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6712 – Failure to Disclose Treaty-Based Return Positions These stack with other tax penalties, though Treasury can waive them for reasonable cause and good faith.

The larger risk is the statute of limitations. If a foreign company had a permanent establishment and never filed a U.S. return for it, the normal three-year assessment window never begins. Under IRC Section 6501(c)(3), the IRS can assess tax at any time when no return has been filed.16Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6501 – Limitations on Assessment and Collection A company that has operated for years under the wrong assumption about its PE status can face liability stretching back to year one.

If Both Countries Tax the Same Income: Mutual Agreement Procedure

Being found to have a PE in one country while remaining taxable at home creates double taxation on the same income. Tax treaties address this through the Mutual Agreement Procedure. A taxpayer who believes a PE determination has produced taxation inconsistent with the treaty can request MAP assistance from the competent authority of its home country. The request generally must be made within three years of the first notification of the disputed tax action.17OECD. Manual on Effective Mutual Agreement Procedures (2026 Edition)

MAP can take years, and the outcome is not guaranteed. Some treaties include a binding arbitration clause when the competent authorities cannot agree within a set period; many do not, leaving the taxpayer with domestic court proceedings in each country as the fallback. The three-year filing deadline is strict under most treaties, and missing it can permanently close the door on MAP relief, so companies that see a PE dispute forming should track notification dates from the first assessment letter forward.