A church can loan money to its members, but the transaction has to be structured carefully or it can jeopardize the church’s 501(c)(3) status and trigger personal penalties for the people who approved it. The short version: charge at least the IRS Applicable Federal Rate, put the loan in a signed promissory note, run the approval through people who aren’t the borrower’s friends or supervisors, and keep the program small and mission-tied enough that it doesn’t start to look like a bank. Whether a church can loan money to its members is the easy question. Whether it should, and how, is where most congregations get into trouble.
Why Lending Puts the Church’s Exemption at Risk
Section 501(c)(3) requires a church to operate exclusively for religious or charitable purposes and forbids any part of its net earnings from benefiting a private individual.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 501 – Exemption From Tax on Corporations, Certain Trusts, Etc. When money starts flowing from the church to individuals in the form of loans, the IRS applies two tests.
The first is private inurement, an absolute prohibition against earnings flowing to insiders: pastors, board members, their family, and anyone else positioned to steer church resources. A cheap loan to the pastor is the textbook example. The second is private benefit, which is broader and covers everyone, insider or not. Any benefit to a private individual has to be incidental to the church’s charitable work. A loan on generous terms to a member who isn’t in genuine need can flunk this test even if the borrower has no leadership role.
The IRS has revoked or denied exemption to organizations whose lending looked like a commercial bank: interest-bearing loans, made for members’ personal use, funded out of interest income rather than voluntary contributions.2Internal Revenue Service. Final Determination Letter Regarding Application for Recognition of Exemption Under Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(3) The more your lending resembles a business, the harder it is to defend as charity.
Personal Penalties on Insiders and Church Managers
Even when the church keeps its exemption, the people involved can be hit personally. Under Section 4958, if the IRS calls a loan to an insider an “excess benefit transaction,” the insider owes an initial tax of 25% of the excess benefit. If they don’t unwind the transaction before the IRS assesses the tax, a second-tier penalty of 200% applies.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4958 – Taxes on Excess Benefit Transactions
Church managers who knowingly approved the deal face their own penalty, capped at $20,000 per transaction, with joint and several liability if more than one manager is on the hook.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4958 – Taxes on Excess Benefit Transactions A single sloppy loan approval can leave a board member personally owing tens of thousands of dollars.
The Minimum Interest Rate
The fastest way to turn a church loan into a private benefit is to charge too little interest. Section 7872 treats any loan below the Applicable Federal Rate as a “below-market loan” and recharacterizes the forgone interest as a transfer from lender to borrower.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7872 – Treatment of Loans With Below-Market Interest Rates For a church, that recharacterized transfer is the private benefit.
The AFR is published monthly by the IRS in three tiers based on loan term. As of December 2025, the annual-compounding rates were roughly 3.66% for short-term loans (up to three years), 3.79% for mid-term loans (three to nine years), and 4.55% for long-term loans (over nine years).5Internal Revenue Service. Rev. Rul. 2025-24 – Applicable Federal Rates for December 2025 Lock in the rate for the month you originate the loan and write it into the note.
Section 7872 has a $10,000 de minimis exception, but it’s narrower than churches usually assume. The gift-loan exception is only for loans between individuals, not from an organization. A separate $10,000 exception covers employer-employee loans, which could reach loans to paid staff but not to regular members.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7872 – Treatment of Loans With Below-Market Interest Rates The clean rule for any church loan is to charge at least the AFR regardless of amount.
Would a Benevolence Grant Be Better?
Before setting up a loan, ask whether an outright grant fits the situation. Benevolence payments to people in genuine hardship are a recognized charitable activity and sidestep the repayment and private-benefit problems that come with lending. The IRS has drawn a clear line between organizations that give grants and interest-free loans to further religious purposes and those that run interest-bearing lending programs for members’ personal use.2Internal Revenue Service. Final Determination Letter Regarding Application for Recognition of Exemption Under Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(3)
A defensible benevolence program uses a written application, requires supporting documentation of hardship (bills, bank statements, pay stubs), and applies written eligibility criteria tied to the church’s mission. Where the goal is to help someone through a crisis, a grant is usually the cleaner path.
State Usury Caps and Lending Licenses
Federal tax law isn’t the only regime that applies. Every state caps the interest a non-bank lender can charge. General maximums typically run somewhere between 6% and 15%, though some states allow more for certain written contracts. Because you should already be charging at least the AFR, the practical exercise is confirming your rate stays under the state ceiling, which at current rates is rarely tight.
Licensing is the sharper edge. Many states require anyone who makes loans on a regular basis to hold a lending license, and thresholds can be as low as three to five loans per year. A one-off loan almost never trips the requirement; a standing program with steady activity can. Lending without a required license can bring fines and can render existing loans unenforceable, so check your state’s rules before you launch anything formal.
What About Truth in Lending Disclosures?
The federal Truth in Lending Act, through Regulation Z, requires disclosures only from “creditors,” defined as those who extended consumer credit more than 25 times in the prior calendar year, or more than five times if the loans were secured by a dwelling.6eCFR. 12 CFR 1026.2 – Definitions and Rules of Construction Most church programs sit well below that. If you’re making more than five dwelling-secured loans a year, you’re in Regulation Z territory and need the full disclosure package.
Structuring the Program
Ad hoc lending is where churches get burned. A pastor quietly approving $5,000 for a friend leaves no paper trail and no defense against a private-benefit claim. A written loan policy forces consistency before any money moves. At a minimum, the policy should set:
- Eligibility criteria tied to the church’s charitable mission.
- A standard application form completed by every applicant.
- Loan limits per borrower and in aggregate for the program.
- An interest rate of at least the AFR for the applicable term.
- A review committee independent of church leadership that decides every application.
Independence on that committee is the piece most churches skip and the piece that matters most. If the pastor votes on loans, the IRS has an easy argument that insiders are steering benefits. The committee should report to the governing board and exclude anyone who requested or originated the loan under review.
Documenting the Loan
Every loan needs a signed promissory note. Without one, the IRS can recharacterize the payment as a gift or disguised distribution, which makes the private-benefit picture much worse. The note is your evidence that this was a real loan with real repayment terms. It should identify:
- The parties, with full legal names and addresses.
- The principal amount.
- The annual interest rate, which meets the AFR and falls below the state usury cap.
- The repayment schedule and final maturity date.
- Default terms, including any acceleration of the balance.
Both the borrower and an authorized church representative sign and date it. Keep the original in the church’s records and give the borrower a copy. Then actually enforce the terms. A note sitting in a drawer while the borrower pays whenever they feel like it looks like a gift, and the IRS will treat it that way.
If the Church Later Forgives the Loan
Sometimes a borrower can’t repay and the church writes off the balance. That forgiveness has consequences on both sides. Under Section 108, cancelled debt is generally taxable income to the borrower, so a forgiven $10,000 balance is $10,000 of gross income for that year, with limited exclusions available if the borrower is insolvent or in bankruptcy.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 108 – Income From Discharge of Indebtedness
Form 1099-C filing is required only when lending is a “significant trade or business” for the organization, and the IRS provides safe harbors that most churches fall inside, generally when gross income from lending is under 15% of total gross income and under $5 million.8Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Forms 1099-A and 1099-C The borrower still owes tax on the cancelled amount whether or not a 1099-C is filed.
Forgiving an insider’s loan is the dangerous case. Writing off a pastor’s balance is functionally the same as paying the pastor a bonus in that amount, and the IRS treats it as an excess benefit transaction under Section 4958. Expect the same 25% and 200% penalties on the insider and up to $20,000 per manager for the people who approved the write-off.
Do Churches Owe Tax on the Interest They Collect?
No. Section 512(b)(1) excludes interest, dividends, and annuities from unrelated business taxable income, so interest a church earns on member loans isn’t taxed.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 512 – Unrelated Business Taxable Income That’s a separate question from whether the lending itself is compatible with the church’s exempt purpose. A church can collect untaxed interest and still lose its exemption if the program mainly serves private ends.