Colonel James Sabow: Death, Forensic Disputes, and Court Rulings

Colonel James E. Sabow, a 51-year-old Marine Corps officer, was found shot to death in the backyard of his home at Marine Corps Air Station El Toro in Orange County, California, on January 22, 1991, five days after being relieved of his post amid a military investigation into the misuse of government aircraft. Every official inquiry into Colonel James Sabow’s death — by the Naval Investigative Service, the Judge Advocate General, the FBI, the Defense Department, and an independent forensic analyst commissioned by Congress in 2004 — has concluded he took his own life with a 12-gauge shotgun. His family, led by his brother Dr. J. David Sabow, has spent more than three decades arguing he was murdered, and lost every claim they brought in federal court.

Why Sabow Was Under Investigation

In late 1990, the Marine Corps Inspector General’s office opened a probe into the personal use of military aircraft at MCAS El Toro after an anonymous tip to a Pentagon fraud hotline. Pilots identified Sabow and Colonel Joseph E. Underwood, the base’s chief of staff, as members of an informal “fliers’ club” that allegedly used C-12 twin-engine turboprops for personal travel, including weekend golf trips to the East Coast.1Los Angeles Times. Slain Officer’s Family Still Fights for Answers

Underwood was suspended on January 12, 1991. Sabow was relieved as assistant chief of staff on January 17.2Los Angeles Times. Two Top Officers at El Toro Suspended in Inquiry That same day, Inspector General Hollis Davison briefed the base commander, Brigadier General Wayne T. Adams, on the progress of the investigation and potential charges.3U.S. District Court, Central District of California. Sabow v. United States, SA CV 93-991 AHS Five days later Sabow was dead. The Inspector General’s inquiry into his alleged misconduct ended without ever reaching a formal conclusion on the aircraft-use allegations against him.4Los Angeles Times. Family Files Claim in Officer’s Death

What the Official Investigations Found

On the morning of January 22, 1991, Sabow was found lying on his right side in the grass beside an overturned patio chair. A 12-gauge Ithaca shotgun was positioned between his knees.5Los Angeles Times. Brother Won’t Accept Suicide Ruling in Colonel’s Death The Naval Investigative Service — later renamed NCIS — led the death investigation and issued its report on August 27, 1991. Two follow-up reviews by the Office of the Judge Advocate General reached the same finding. All three ruled the death a suicide.6FindLaw. Sabow v. United States, No. 94-56634

Later reviews by the FBI and the Defense Department upheld that conclusion. The official explanation held that Sabow could not cope with the professional disgrace of being relieved of duty and placed under investigation.5Los Angeles Times. Brother Won’t Accept Suicide Ruling in Colonel’s Death

The Forensic Anomalies the Family Points To

Dr. J. David Sabow, a board-certified neurosurgeon in South Dakota, rejected the suicide finding almost immediately and brought in outside forensic analysts. The family has focused on three physical findings.

Colonel Sabow’s fingerprints were not on the shotgun. The only prints on the weapon belonged to his son, who had cleaned it previously. There were no fingerprints on the ammunition boxes either.5Los Angeles Times. Brother Won’t Accept Suicide Ruling in Colonel’s Death

The Orange County coroner found a large quantity of aspirated blood in Sabow’s right lung. Dr. Sabow argued this was physically impossible if the shotgun blast destroyed the brain stem, which controls breathing. In his reading, someone struck the colonel on the head first, causing blood to drain into his nasal cavity and be inhaled while he was still unconscious but breathing, and only then was the shotgun fired.7OC Weekly. Cold Case at the Marine Base

The scene was described as nearly bloodless. A sizable spray of blood appeared only on Sabow’s left forearm and palm, ending in a clean line. Dr. Sabow argued that pattern was consistent with the colonel already lying on his right side when the shotgun discharged, not sitting upright as a self-inflicted wound would suggest.7OC Weekly. Cold Case at the Marine Base

Military officials responded that the colonel could have drawn a breath after the shot and that missing fingerprints on a weapon are not unusual.5Los Angeles Times. Brother Won’t Accept Suicide Ruling in Colonel’s Death The family has also alleged the scene was mishandled: not properly secured, evidence moved before being photographed, and the body left in the sun for more than seven hours.6FindLaw. Sabow v. United States, No. 94-56634

The Drug-Trafficking Theory

Dr. Sabow and supporters of the murder theory have long claimed the colonel was killed because he had learned of covert drug- and weapons-smuggling operations moving through MCAS El Toro, allegedly from Central America, and intended to expose them.8CBS News. Marine Col. James Sabow’s Family on Pentagon Shooter

Attorney Daniel Sheehan, who filed a federal lawsuit for Dr. Sabow in January 2000, folded these allegations into the litigation. His briefs cited anonymous claims that black-painted cargo planes were landing at El Toro after midnight and referred to a purported federal drug investigation known as “Operation Emerald Clipper.” The sources were largely anonymous. Dr. Sabow later distanced himself from Sheehan, citing concerns about his “duplicity,” though he continued to believe in the broader conspiracy.7OC Weekly. Cold Case at the Marine Base No government entity has ever substantiated the drug-trafficking allegations.

General Adams and the Family

A separate strand of the controversy concerns Brigadier General Wayne T. Adams, the El Toro commander. On March 9, 1991, Adams held a five-hour meeting with the colonel’s widow, Sara Sabow, and Dr. Sabow in his office, at which NIS agents Barrett and Nakasone presented the investigation’s findings. Court records allege that Adams berated the family and called the colonel a “crook” and a “felon,” even though no formal charges had been filed.6FindLaw. Sabow v. United States, No. 94-56634

When Dr. Sabow began challenging the suicide finding publicly, Adams allegedly ordered subordinates to look into how to “go after” Dr. Sabow’s medical license in South Dakota. A complaint letter to state licensing authorities was drafted but never sent; a copy was allowed to reach Dr. Sabow in what the family described as intimidation.6FindLaw. Sabow v. United States, No. 94-56634

Adams himself was under investigation for personal use of military aircraft, including flights to see his fiancée and a side trip to Florida to sign divorce papers. In May 1991 the Marine Corps removed him from command at El Toro and reassigned him to Quantico, Virginia.9Los Angeles Times. General Reassigned Amid Probe of Plane Use He was formally reprimanded in August 1991 and retired in February 1992.10The Seattle Times. Military Justice May Have Some General Flaws

What Happened in Court

In October 1992 the Sabow family filed a $10 million administrative claim against the military, alleging a conspiracy to conceal the facts of the death, falsify official records, intimidate the family, and disqualify Sara Sabow from military benefits.4Los Angeles Times. Family Files Claim in Officer’s Death

In June 1994 they sued in federal court under the Federal Tort Claims Act. In August 1996 the Ninth Circuit upheld dismissal of the claims tied to the NIS and JAG investigations and the claim for negligent handling of remains, finding that investigators had exercised protected discretionary judgment. It did revive the claims about General Adams’s personal conduct at the March 1991 meeting and his moves against Dr. Sabow’s medical license, sending those back to the district court for trial.6FindLaw. Sabow v. United States, No. 94-56634 On remand, a bench trial ended in judgment for the government.11U.S. District Court, Central District of California. Sara T. Sabow, et al v. USA, et al

The 2004 Congressional Review

Representative Duncan Hunter, then chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, inserted a provision in the 2004 Defense Authorization Act requiring the Pentagon to conduct a fresh, independent review.12The Christian Science Monitor. Marine Col. James Sabow Coverup Questions Surface Again The review was led by Jon Nordby, a criminal forensic analyst. Nordby concluded the death was a suicide, matching every prior official finding, while acknowledging that mistakes had been made in the earlier investigations.13The Christian Science Monitor. Col. James Sabow: Pentagon Shooter Was Obsessed With 1991 Case

The 2010 Pentagon Shooting Connection

The case briefly returned to national attention in March 2010, when John Patrick Bedell, a California man, opened fire on police officers outside the Pentagon, wounding two before being fatally shot. Investigators found that Bedell had been deeply obsessed with the Sabow case, treating it as evidence of a government “narco-conspiracy.” He had spent years, starting around 2006, trying to insert conspiracy-related material into Wikipedia entries about the case.14Anti-Defamation League. John Patrick Bedell and the Lethal Lure of Conspiracy Theories Dr. Sabow said the family had no connection to Bedell, called him “a nut,” and worried that intelligence agencies would use the shooting to discredit the evidence he believed supported the murder theory.8CBS News. Marine Col. James Sabow’s Family on Pentagon Shooter

The case remains, on the official record, a closed suicide. It also remains, in the record of the family’s contested forensic questions and the 2004 concession that earlier investigators made mistakes, a death that a portion of the public has never accepted as fully explained.