Common Probate Issues: Will Challenges, Debts, and Heir Disputes

Common probate issues fall into a short list of predictable trouble spots: challenges to the will, executor misconduct, creditor claims, missing assets, family fights over property, and unpaid taxes. Even a clean estate typically takes nine to eighteen months to close, and any of these problems can push a case past two years. Knowing where they surface, and what to do when they do, is what keeps a case moving.

Challenges to the Will

A will contest is the most disruptive thing that can happen in probate. If the court throws out the document, every plan the deceased made goes with it.

The most common attack is that the person lacked the mental capacity to sign. Courts look at whether they understood what they owned, who their family was, and what signing the document would do to those relatives’ right to inherit.1Justia. Lack of Testamentary Capacity Legally Invalidating a Will A related claim is undue influence, usually raised when an elderly or dependent person made changes favoring a caretaker or a single family member who controlled their daily life.

Technical defects sink more wills than most families expect. Most states require two witnesses who don’t inherit under the document, and some require notarization for the will to be self-proving. A missing signature, a beneficiary who also served as witness, or a document that was never properly executed can render the whole thing unenforceable no matter how clearly it reflects the person’s wishes.

When a will fails, the estate falls into intestacy and state law takes over. A rigid formula distributes property first to a surviving spouse and children, then outward to parents, siblings, and more distant relatives.2Legal Information Institute. Intestate Succession Verbal promises count for nothing, caregiving history is ignored, and if no qualifying relatives exist the entire estate goes to the state.

Executor Misconduct

The executor holds a legal duty to manage the estate honestly for the people who are supposed to inherit. Courts can require them to post a bond before taking office, which functions as insurance if they cause financial harm.

Problems follow a familiar pattern. Commingling is the most common: depositing estate funds into a personal account or using estate money for personal expenses, even briefly. Self-dealing is next, such as buying estate property at a discount or paying oneself fees without court authorization. Both violate the executor’s duty of loyalty and can trigger immediate court intervention.

When the court finds the executor caused financial harm, it can order a surcharge that forces repayment from personal funds. Missing court-ordered deadlines for inventories or accountings is grounds for removal. Outright theft can bring criminal prosecution under state embezzlement statutes. Beyond the money, a breach typically adds months or years to the case while a replacement is appointed and gets up to speed.

Debts and Creditor Claims

Every legitimate debt must be paid before any beneficiary receives anything. The executor publishes a formal notice in a local newspaper opening a filing window for creditors, usually two to six months depending on the state.

When debts exceed assets, the estate is insolvent and state law sets a strict payment order: court costs and administrative expenses first, then funeral costs, taxes, medical bills, and finally unsecured debts like credit cards. Lower-priority creditors get nothing until higher categories are paid in full.

The trap for executors is distributing property before the creditor window closes. If a valid claim shows up later and the estate is empty, the executor can be held personally liable for the shortfall.3Internal Revenue Service. Publication 559, Survivors, Executors, and Administrators Creditors can also petition the court to claw back assets already handed to beneficiaries, converting what looked like an inheritance into a lawsuit.

Student Loans

Federal student loans are discharged when the borrower dies and don’t become a claim against the estate. A family member submits a certified death certificate to the loan servicer to start the discharge.4eCFR. 34 CFR 674.61 – Discharge for Death or Disability Parent PLUS loans are also canceled if either the parent borrower or the student dies. Private student loans follow no uniform rule; some lenders discharge the balance, others pursue the estate or a cosigner. The original loan agreement is the only reliable source.

Missing or Hidden Assets

Before anything can be distributed, the executor has to find everything the deceased owned. That gets hard fast with someone who kept accounts at multiple banks, held a safety deposit box no one knew about, or stored cryptocurrency in a wallet with no written password. Overlooking assets isn’t just a delay; a sloppy search can expose the executor to liability.

Digital assets are the growing edge of this problem. Email, online brokerages, photo libraries with licensing value, and monetized social accounts all need to be identified, valued, and either transferred or closed. Without a list of accounts and credentials, the executor may have to petition each platform separately, and some make that deliberately difficult.

Title defects create a different headache. A deed never updated after a divorce, or a car title still listing a co-owner who died years earlier, requires corrective filings before the property can transfer. State unclaimed property divisions are worth searching for dormant accounts, uncashed insurance checks, and old utility deposits. Unusual property such as fine art, antique collections, or private business interests needs professional appraisal, and heirs frequently fight over the resulting numbers.

Disputes Among Heirs

Family conflict is where probate cases go to die. A will directing that “personal belongings go to my children equally” reads clearly enough until three siblings are arguing over the piano, the photo albums, and the engagement ring. Sentimental items with little market value become the most bitterly contested property in the estate, and the legal bill can dwarf what they’re worth.

Omitted heirs are a more structured issue. Most states have statutes protecting children or spouses left out of a will, especially when born or adopted after signing. These laws generally treat the omission as accidental and let the excluded person claim the share they’d have received under intestacy.5Legal Information Institute. Omitted Heir Specific language acknowledging and intentionally excluding a person prevents these claims, but many wills don’t include it.

The litigation runs expensive. Probate attorneys charge roughly $225 to $400 per hour depending on the market, and contested cases involve depositions, expert witnesses, and sometimes trial. Fees usually come out of the estate, so every dollar spent on lawyers is a dollar no beneficiary sees. Small estates can be consumed entirely, leaving nothing to divide.

Unpaid Taxes

Tax obligations transfer to the executor. They must file a final individual income tax return covering the year the person died, plus any prior-year returns that were never filed.6Internal Revenue Service. Deceased Person If the estate itself earns more than $600 during administration from interest, rent, or asset sales, the executor also files a separate estate income tax return on Form 1041.7Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 1041 and Schedules A, B, G, J, and K-1

An executor who distributes assets before paying the tax bill can be held personally liable up to the value of what was distributed.3Internal Revenue Service. Publication 559, Survivors, Executors, and Administrators To protect against that risk, executors can file Form 5495 with the IRS requesting formal discharge from personal liability for the deceased person’s income, gift, and estate taxes.8Internal Revenue Service. About Form 5495, Request for Discharge From Personal Liability Under IRC Section 2204 or 6905 Most probate courts won’t close an estate until the IRS and state tax authorities confirm nothing further is owed.

For 2026, the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person, a figure set by legislation signed into law on July 4, 2025.9Internal Revenue Service. Whats New — Estate and Gift Tax Only the portion above that threshold is taxed, at a top rate of 40%. A surviving spouse can also use any unused portion of the deceased spouse’s exemption, effectively doubling the sheltered amount for married couples.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 2010 – Unified Credit Against Estate Tax Most estates fall well below the threshold, but those that don’t face a bill the executor must settle before closing.

Assets That Skip Probate Entirely

Some property never touches the probate court, and misunderstanding this causes real problems. Life insurance with a named beneficiary, retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs, bank accounts with payable-on-death designations, investment accounts with transfer-on-death registrations, and property held in joint tenancy with right of survivorship all pass directly to the named person.11Legal Information Institute. Nonprobate Transfer

Beneficiary designations override the will. If a retirement account still names an ex-spouse and the will leaves everything to a current partner, the ex-spouse gets the account. Failing to update designations after divorce, remarriage, or a beneficiary’s death is one of the most common and most preventable estate planning mistakes.

Revocable living trusts also bypass probate. Property transferred into a properly funded trust during life passes to the trust’s beneficiaries under the trust document, with no court involvement and no public record. The catch is that assets the owner never actually retitled into the trust still go through probate. An unfunded trust is a safe with nothing inside it.

Whether Full Probate Is Even Needed

Every state offers a simplified procedure for estates below a certain value. Small estate affidavits let heirs collect property by filing a sworn statement with the institution holding the asset instead of opening a court case. Thresholds range widely, from as low as $10,000 in some states to $200,000 in others, and many states exclude real estate or vehicles from the calculation.

Typical requirements include a waiting period after death of roughly 30 to 45 days, a certified death certificate, and proof the claimant is legally entitled to the property. Some states also require that no formal probate case has been opened. For a modest bank account or a single vehicle, this can wrap up in weeks for little more than a filing fee.

Estates that exceed the small-estate threshold may still qualify for a shorter court procedure sometimes called summary administration. These abbreviated processes skip full accountings and extended creditor notice periods and generally close in three to six months. Checking whether either alternative applies before filing regular probate can save thousands in legal fees and months of waiting.