Directed Trusts and Powers to Direct Under the UDTA

Directed trusts under the UDTA divide the job of running a trust between two roles: a trust director, who makes decisions about investments, distributions, or specific assets, and a directed trustee, who handles custody, recordkeeping, tax reporting, and carrying out the director’s instructions. The Uniform Directed Trust Act, finalized by the Uniform Law Commission in 2017 and adopted in a growing number of states, gives that split a clear legal framework: it defines what counts as a “power of direction,” sets the fiduciary standards for each role, and shifts liability so that the trustee is generally protected when following a director’s valid instructions.

How the Split Works

A conventional trustee does everything. That works for straightforward portfolios and breaks down when a trust holds assets that need specialized knowledge, such as a family business, a concentrated stock position, private equity, or real estate. A corporate trustee fluent in public securities may have no business running a ranch.

A directed trust solves that by dividing authority in the trust document itself. The director’s authority does not flow from the trustee. It comes straight from the instrument, which is what distinguishes this structure from a delegated trust, where a single trustee hires an outside advisor as an agent while keeping ultimate responsibility.

The director can be an individual, a committee, or a business entity. Trust documents often call the same role an advisor, protector, or investment committee, but under the UDTA the person holding a power of direction is a trust director regardless of the label.

The Trust Director: Powers and Duties

The trust document defines who serves as director, what qualifications the role requires, and how vacancies are filled. A settlor might require an investment director to hold a Chartered Financial Analyst designation or a distribution director to be a family member over a certain age. If a position becomes vacant, the trust should say who names a replacement, or a court can step in when no other process exists.

Common powers of direction include:

  • Choosing investments and setting strategy.
  • Deciding the timing and amount of distributions, sometimes tied to milestones like graduating from college or reaching a certain age.
  • Managing a specific asset, such as a closely held company or real estate holding.

A director also has any “further powers” reasonably necessary to carry out the granted power. A director with investment authority can select brokers and approve transaction costs because those steps logically follow. When multiple directors share a power, they act by majority unless the document says otherwise.

By default, a director owes the same fiduciary duties as a trustee holding the same power. A director acting alone is measured against the standard of a sole trustee; a director sharing power is measured against the standard of a cotrustee. That means acting in the beneficiaries’ interests, using reasonable care and skill, and staying loyal to the trust’s purposes. The trust document can raise or lower these duties within limits, but there are outer boundaries on how far obligations can be reduced.

One carve-out is worth flagging. If a director is licensed to provide healthcare and acts in that capacity (a physician making medical-needs assessments for distribution decisions, for example), the UDTA imposes no fiduciary duty for those healthcare-related actions unless the trust document says otherwise.

A director who breaches these duties faces personal liability, including the obligation to restore any loss the trust suffered. Courts can also remove a director who fails to meet the standard.

The Directed Trustee: Duty to Comply and the Willful Misconduct Line

The directed trustee’s core job is simple to state. Under Section 9 of the UDTA, the trustee must comply with the director’s exercise or nonexercise of a power of direction. There is one exception: the trustee must refuse if compliance would constitute willful misconduct.

That threshold sits deliberately high. The UDTA does not define willful misconduct, and the term has generated real debate. Some states with older directed trust statutes defined it as intentional wrongdoing that goes beyond negligence, gross negligence, or even recklessness, requiring something closer to malicious conduct or an attempt to gain an unconscionable advantage. Under any reading, the bar is well above ordinary carelessness. A trustee who thinks the director’s investment strategy is unwise, or who disagrees with a distribution call, cannot refuse on that basis. Refusal is reserved for instructions that would cross into deliberate illegality or intentional harm.

In exchange, the directed trustee gets broad liability protection. A trustee who follows a valid instruction is not liable for the consequences of that decision. The trustee has no duty to monitor the director’s judgment, second-guess investment choices, or offer unsolicited advice about matters inside the director’s authority. This liability shift is the defining feature of the model. It lets the administrative trustee focus on execution while the director carries responsibility for the substance.

Information Sharing

The UDTA requires both parties to share information reasonably related to the other’s duties. If the trustee holds financial statements the director needs for an investment decision, the trustee has to provide them. If the director makes a distribution call, the director has to give the trustee enough detail to pay it correctly.

There is a safe harbor built in. Neither party is liable for a failure caused by the other’s refusal to share necessary information, so long as the party requesting the information acted in good faith. A trustee who cannot execute a distribution because the director never sent the details is not on the hook for the delay. A director who made a poor call because the trustee withheld financial data has a defense. This keeps divided authority from turning into a trap where each side can be blamed for the other’s silence.

Powers the UDTA Does Not Cover

Not every power in a trust document is a “power of direction” under the act. Section 5 excludes several categories, and those powers carry their own legal rules rather than the UDTA’s fiduciary and liability provisions:

  • Powers of appointment, when exercised in a nonfiduciary capacity.
  • The power to appoint or remove a trustee or trust director. This is a governance power, not a power of direction.
  • A settlor’s retained power to revoke or amend the trust.
  • Beneficiary powers that directly affect the beneficiary’s own interest, or the interest of someone the beneficiary represents.
  • Powers that the trust terms designate as nonfiduciary to achieve the settlor’s tax objectives under the Internal Revenue Code.

The distinction matters. Someone with authority to remove and replace trustees is not acting as a trust director under the UDTA and is not subject to the act’s fiduciary standards for that role. Drafters have to be precise about which powers sit inside the UDTA framework and which sit outside, because the duty standards and liability protections differ.

Tax Traps in Director Powers

Two federal tax issues deserve attention when a trust document assigns powers to a director.

The first is grantor trust status. Certain administrative powers held in a nonfiduciary capacity can cause the trust to be treated as a grantor trust, meaning the grantor rather than the trust pays income tax on trust earnings. These include the power to direct the voting of stock in a corporation where the grantor and trust together hold significant voting control, the power to control investment decisions involving such stock, and the power to reacquire trust assets by substituting property of equal value. If a director holds one of these powers in a nonfiduciary capacity without the consent of someone acting in a fiduciary capacity, the trust can be pulled into grantor trust treatment regardless of what the settlor intended.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 675 – Administrative Powers Whether that result helps or hurts depends on the estate plan; sometimes grantor treatment is the goal, sometimes it defeats the point of the trust.

The second is estate inclusion. If a director holds what the IRS treats as a general power of appointment, the trust assets can be pulled into the director’s taxable estate at death. A general power exists when the holder can direct property to themselves, their estate, their creditors, or the creditors of their estate. A power limited by an ascertainable standard tied to health, education, support, or maintenance is not a general power of appointment. A pure fiduciary power of management or investment, where the holder cannot shift beneficial interests except as an incidental consequence of fiduciary duties, is not treated as a power of appointment at all.2eCFR. 26 CFR 20.2041-1 – Powers of Appointment; In General

The UDTA acknowledges the tax dimension in Section 5 by excluding any power the trust terms designate as nonfiduciary when that designation is needed to reach the settlor’s tax objectives. That gives drafters room to structure specific powers outside the UDTA’s fiduciary regime when tax rules demand it. Getting these designations wrong is expensive, so the interaction between director powers and federal tax law is where the drafting has to be precise.

Directed Trust or Delegated Trust

The two terms sound alike and describe different structures. In a directed trust, the document itself splits authority from the outset. The director’s power comes from the instrument. The trustee never held that authority to begin with.

In a delegated trust, a single trustee starts with full authority and hires an outside advisor, usually for investment management, as the trustee’s agent. The advisor works for the trustee. The trustee keeps ultimate responsibility and continues to handle distributions and administration, and remains accountable for the advisor’s performance to a degree that varies by jurisdiction.

The practical difference is where liability lands. Under the UDTA, a directed trustee is generally shielded from liability for decisions inside the director’s authority. In a delegated trust, the trustee who chose to delegate carries ongoing oversight responsibility. Families who want a specific person to make investment or distribution calls, and to bear direct fiduciary responsibility for those calls, tend to prefer the directed model. Families who want a single institution to maintain overall accountability tend to prefer delegation.