EarnIn Lawsuits: DC Suit, Class Actions, and Arbitration Claims

EarnIn, the cash advance app formally known as ActiveHours Inc., is the defendant in several active lawsuits that accuse it of running an unlicensed lending operation dressed up as “earned wage access.” The EarnIn lawsuits currently on file include a District of Columbia enforcement action that was largely dismissed and is now closed on appeal, federal class actions in Maryland and California that survived motions to dismiss and are moving forward, and a separate individual arbitration campaign that stopped accepting new clients in July 2025. An older class action over bank overdraft fees settled in 2021 for $12.5 million and is fully administered.1Perks v. Activehours, Inc., No. 5:19-cv-05543-BLF (N.D. Cal.).

District of Columbia v. EarnIn

DC Attorney General Brian Schwalb sued EarnIn on November 19, 2024, alleging the company advertised Cash Out as fee-free while charging “Lightning Speed” fees and soliciting tips that, calculated as an annual percentage rate, averaged over 300% — well above the District’s 24% cap. The complaint said EarnIn was operating as an unlicensed lender and that more than 20,000 DC consumers had run over a million transactions through the app since 2016.

In May 2025, a DC Superior Court judge dismissed most of the AG’s claims, ruling that no DC statute classifies earned wage access products as loans and that the Department of Insurance, Securities, and Banking, not the AG’s office, is the right body to decide the question. On February 6, 2026, the DC Court of Appeals denied the AG’s request to appeal, leaving the dismissal in place. According to the Center for Responsible Lending’s litigation tracker, the trial court did allow some deceptive-practice claims to move forward even while deferring the lending-classification question.

Karl Racine, the former DC attorney general who led EarnIn’s defense at Hogan Lovells, said the ruling confirmed the product “has not been established to be a loan under current District law.” His co-counsel Jason Downs said “regulators and legislators, not litigants, are best equipped to assess the policy implications of new financial tools.”

Johnson v. Activehours (Maryland Federal Class Action)

In Johnson v. Activehours, Inc., No. 1:24-cv-02283 (D. Md.), lead plaintiff Alisa Johnson and a putative class of Maryland and Delaware users allege that EarnIn violated the Maryland Consumer Loan Law and the federal Truth in Lending Act by lending without a license and skipping required disclosures.

On August 8, 2025, U.S. District Judge Julie Rubin denied EarnIn’s motion to dismiss the lending-law claims. She found the plaintiffs plausibly alleged EarnIn is in the business of making loans, that Lightning Speed fees and tips can be characterized as interest or service charges, and that the product meets the definition of “credit” under Regulation Z. Judge Rubin rejected EarnIn’s argument that it isn’t a lender because it doesn’t require repayment or charge traditional interest, pointing to the app’s requirement that users connect employer-linked bank accounts. She did dismiss a separate Maryland Consumer Protection Act claim, finding the plaintiffs hadn’t adequately alleged reliance on specific misrepresentations. The case is proceeding on the surviving claims.

Orubo v. Activehours (California Federal Class Action)

A parallel class action, Orubo v. Activehours, Inc., No. 5:24-cv-04702-PCP (N.D. Cal.), was filed by four plaintiffs: Brennan Orubo, Michael Sims, Demetrice Mathis, and Cidney Lett. The complaint alleges that Lightning Speed fees are effectively mandatory because users need funds immediately, producing APRs the plaintiffs calculated at 130% to 1,700%, and that tips are extracted through confusing navigation, default tip amounts, and guilt-inducing language. The suit brings claims under the Truth in Lending Act and the Georgia Payday Loan Act, among others, and seeks treble damages, restitution, and a declaration that the advances are void.

On April 30, 2025, the court denied EarnIn’s motion to dismiss and the case is moving forward. As of mid-2025, EarnIn was also facing a similar consumer lawsuit in a Pennsylvania federal court.

Perks v. Activehours: The 2021 Overdraft Settlement

The one EarnIn class action that has already paid out is Perks v. Activehours, Inc., No. 5:19-cv-05543-BLF (N.D. Cal.). Plaintiffs alleged EarnIn’s withdrawals triggered overdraft and non-sufficient funds fees at users’ banks, contradicting marketing that promised “no fees, costs, or hidden charges.”

Judge Beth Labson Freeman granted final approval on March 25, 2021 to a settlement valued at $12.5 million. The class covered consumers who incurred an overdraft or NSF fee tied to an EarnIn withdrawal between September 3, 2015 and May 28, 2020. The case has been fully administered and is closed, so no new claims can be filed against that fund.

Individual Arbitration Claims

Because EarnIn’s terms of service include an arbitration clause, many consumer disputes never reach court. The law firms Labaton Keller Sucharow and Berger Montague ran a coordinated arbitration campaign accusing EarnIn of operating Cash Out as an undisclosed loan without adequate cost disclosures. Eligible users were told they might recover up to $400 or more depending on their state. The proceedings were confidential. As of July 2025, the firms had closed the campaign to new clients.

How These Cases Fit Together

The lawsuits split along a fault line courts across the country are still working out: whether an advance against your next paycheck, priced through expedited-delivery fees and app-solicited tips, is a loan. The DC courts said the AG couldn’t answer that through litigation and left it to financial regulators. The Maryland and California federal courts said the plaintiffs’ allegations were enough to keep going. According to the Center for Responsible Lending’s tracker, every federal court that has analyzed whether EWA advances are credit has concluded that they are. In April 2026, U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman in the Southern District of New York denied a motion to dismiss in Feeman v. Bridge It, Inc., No. 1:25-cv-03806, finding a competitor’s product “substantially similar” to payday loans; that decision was described as the twelfth federal ruling to treat EWA cash advances as loans subject to lending laws.

Federal policy has moved the other direction. On December 23, 2025, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau withdrew a 2024 proposed rule that would have treated all fee-charging EWA products as consumer loans and issued an advisory opinion creating a narrow “Covered EWA” safe harbor for products that use actual payroll data, payroll-based deductions, no recourse against the worker, and no individual credit risk assessment. For products outside that safe harbor, the CFPB said expedited fees and tips are generally not finance charges “in the normal course,” though they may be if the provider makes them hard to avoid.

State legislatures are heading in opposite directions. Nevada, Missouri, Wisconsin, Kansas, and South Carolina have enacted laws regulating EWA as its own category, effectively exempting these products from traditional lending rules while adding licensing and disclosure requirements. New York’s Stop Taking Our Pay (STOP) Act, introduced in January 2026 as S8939 and A9644, would go the other way and classify all wage and cash advances as loans subject to state usury caps, treating tips and subscription costs as finance charges regardless of how they’re labeled. The bill remained in the Senate Judiciary Committee as of mid-2026.

For a current or former EarnIn user, the practical picture is this. The DC enforcement action will not produce consumer restitution on the lending claims. The 2021 overdraft settlement is closed. The individual arbitration route is no longer accepting new clients through the firms that ran it. The Maryland and California class actions are the live cases where relief for users is still possible, and both are early in their post-dismissal-motion phase, meaning any recovery would be months or years away and depends on how the courts ultimately answer the loan question.

  • 1
    Perks v. Activehours, Inc., No. 5:19-cv-05543-BLF (N.D. Cal.).