Higher Education Lawsuit News: Funding Freezes, DEI Orders, Visas

Higher education lawsuits have surged since early 2025, with federal courts handling dozens of cases challenging funding freezes, DEI restrictions, student visa revocations, admissions data mandates, and the attempted dismantling of the Department of Education itself. A separate private class action accuses 32 elite colleges of using binding early-decision admissions to inflate tuition. Rulings so far have often blocked or narrowed the federal actions, though several cases remain on appeal and the Supreme Court has intervened at least twice.

Funding Freezes at Named Universities

The most visible line of litigation involves federal research funding pulled from specific universities over allegations of campus antisemitism and civil rights violations.

Harvard

In April 2025, the White House froze more than $2 billion in federal research grants and contracts to Harvard. The university sued, and in September 2025 U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs ruled the freeze unlawful under the First Amendment, the Administrative Procedure Act, and Title VI. She found federal officials had used antisemitism as a “smokescreen for a targeted, ideologically-motivated assault” on Harvard and ordered the freeze lifted.1CBS News. Judge Rules Trump Administration’s Funding Freeze for Harvard Was Unlawful

Grants began returning after the ruling, with the National Science Foundation releasing $11 million and the National Institutes of Health releasing $46 million by late 2025.2Nature. Harvard Grant Funds Begin Returning After Court Order The administration appealed in December 2025 and that appeal remains pending.3Higher Ed Dive. 5 Higher Ed Lawsuits to Watch in 2026 No settlement has been reached, though President Trump has publicly demanded at least $500 million as part of any resolution.4PBS NewsHour. Judge Reverses Trump Administration’s Cuts of Billions in Research Funding to Harvard

In a separate action filed March 20, 2026, the Department of Justice sued Harvard for alleged “deliberate indifference” to harassment of Jewish and Israeli students, seeking an outside monitor, a bar on future federal funding, and recovery of grants issued during the alleged noncompliance.5U.S. Department of Justice. Justice Department Sues Harvard University for Antisemitism The case is before U.S. District Judge Richard G. Stearns. Harvard filed a motion to dismiss in May 2026, arguing the claims are outdated and legally deficient.6The Harvard Crimson. Harvard Files Motion to Dismiss DOJ Antisemitism Lawsuit

Columbia and Brown

Columbia settled in July 2025 after the White House cut $400 million in funding that March. Under the three-year agreement, Columbia paid $200 million to the federal government plus $21 million to resolve a related Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigation, and regained access to roughly $1.3 billion in federal funding. The agreement is not an admission of liability, and independent monitor Charles J. Cooper filed his most recent public compliance report in April 2026.7NPR. Columbia Trump Administration Settlement Details8Columbia University. Federal Resolution Agreement

Brown reached its own voluntary agreement on July 30, 2025, resolving three compliance reviews and restoring more than $50 million in frozen research grants. Brown agreed to pay $50 million over ten years to local workforce development organizations, drop programs promoting “unlawful efforts to achieve race-based outcomes,” and provide anonymized annual admissions demographic data to the government. The agreement denies liability and bars further government civil action on the investigated claims.9Brown University. Brown-United States Resolution Agreement

UCLA and the University of California

The administration demanded nearly $1.2 billion from UCLA in August 2025, presenting a 28-page draft settlement that would have required sweeping policy changes in exchange for releasing roughly $500 million in suspended research grants.10Los Angeles Times. Trump DOJ Proposed Settlement Demand Letter UCLA University of California Demands ranged well beyond antisemitism, including ending gender-affirming care for minors at UC medical facilities, barring transgender women from women’s sports, discontinuing race-based scholarships, and refusing to admit foreign students deemed likely to engage in “anti-Western” disruptions.11Inside Higher Ed. Trump UCLA Demand $1.2B Fine, Nix Trans Athlete Wins, More

The University of California rejected the terms. A coalition of 21 labor unions and faculty associations sued, and in November 2025 U.S. District Judge Rita Lin issued a preliminary injunction blocking the settlement demand and prohibiting the government from using funding freezes as leverage to force policy changes on academic freedom, diversity, gender-affirming care, and student protests. Judge Lin called the administration’s actions “coercive and retaliatory.”12CalMatters. UC Federal Funding Lawsuit The DOJ appealed in January 2026 but dropped the appeal a month later after Judge Lin modified her injunction to clarify its constitutional grounding.13Daily Bruin. Trump Administration Drops Appeal of Order Blocking $1.2 Billion UCLA Settlement

The NIH Indirect Cost Cap

The National Institutes of Health tried to cap overhead reimbursement on research grants at 15 percent, a steep cut from negotiated rates that often exceeded 50 percent. Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell led a coalition of 22 attorneys general, and MIT, Brandeis, Tufts, and other institutions filed suits that were consolidated with the state case.14GovTech. Federal Appeals Court Blocks Trump Cuts to University Health Research

Federal courts permanently blocked the cap in April 2025. On January 5, 2026, the First Circuit unanimously affirmed, holding that administrative and facility expenses are legitimate costs for federally funded research. MIT’s president had estimated the cap would have cost the school $30 to $35 million annually. Similar caps attempted at the Departments of Energy and Defense remain under appeal. The National Science Foundation withdrew its appeal in September 2025, and the administration did not petition the Supreme Court before its deadline, effectively concluding the litigation on the NIH side.15American Council on Education. Federal Court Harvard Ruling

DEI Executive Orders and Grant Cancellations

President Trump issued executive orders in the first 48 hours of his second term targeting DEI programs in federal government, higher education, and the private sector. The American Association of University Professors and the National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education sued in Maryland federal court in February 2025, arguing the orders were unconstitutionally vague and chilled academic freedom.16Inside Higher Ed. Higher Ed Organizations Sue Against Trump’s DEI Orders

The district court issued a preliminary nationwide injunction on February 21, 2025. The Fourth Circuit stayed that injunction on March 14, with Chief Judge Albert Diaz writing that while the orders are “undeniably opaque,” the president has broad authority to set funding priorities. In February 2026, the Fourth Circuit vacated the injunction entirely and remanded for further proceedings.17Columbia Spectator. Federal Appeals Court Allows Trump’s Anti-DEI Orders to Move Forward

Separately, Education Department guidance in February and April 2025 restricting DEI practices was struck down in multiple courts. A Maryland federal court vacated the guidance for procedural failures, and courts in New Hampshire and Washington, D.C., issued additional injunctions, some nationwide.18U.S. News & World Report. Trump’s Higher Education Crackdown The administration withdrew its appeal of the “Dear Colleague” letter case, letting the lower court ruling stand.

In late March 2026, Trump signed a new executive order requiring federal contractors to attest they will not engage in “racially discriminatory DEI activities.” AAUP, NADOHE, a University of Maryland faculty group, and the National Association of Minority Contractors sued in April 2026. That case is active.19Higher Ed Dive. Higher Education Groups Challenge Trump’s Latest Anti-DEI Order

On the grant side, the NIH and NSF canceled hundreds of DEI-related awards. In August 2025, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that federal district courts lacked jurisdiction to restore the funding, directing plaintiffs to the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. The Court left intact a lower court finding that NIH’s actions were illegal. Related litigation remains active in the First Circuit and in district court against the NSF.3Higher Ed Dive. 5 Higher Ed Lawsuits to Watch in 2026

Student Visa Revocations and Immigration-Based Speech Cases

By late April 2025, the State Department had changed the legal status of more than 1,800 international students and recent graduates across over 280 institutions, far exceeding Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s initial estimate of 300. Approximately 290 students filed at least 65 suits challenging termination of their Student and Exchange Visitor Information System records, and courts issued temporary orders letting students remain in 35 of those cases.20Inside Higher Ed. Where Students Have Had Their Visas Revoked On April 25, 2025, the administration announced it would restore all terminated SEVIS statuses.

The AAUP and the Middle East Studies Association, joined by campus chapters at Harvard, NYU, and Rutgers, filed AAUP v. Rubio, challenging the arrest, detention, and deportation of noncitizen students and faculty based on political speech. In September 2025, U.S. District Judge William Young ruled that “noncitizens lawfully present here in the United States actually have the same free speech rights as the rest of us.” In January 2026, Judge Young issued a final order requiring reinstatement of the plaintiffs’ immigration status and establishing that future adverse immigration actions against member plaintiffs would be presumed retaliatory absent clear and convincing evidence otherwise.21Presidents’ Alliance. Visa Revocation Litigation

In a related case, The Stanford Daily sued Rubio and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, alleging the administration used Cold War-era immigration provisions to target noncitizen students and journalists for protected speech. In January 2026, U.S. District Judge Noël Wise denied the government’s motion to dismiss, finding the paper had standing because noncitizen contributors face “well-founded fears of immigration consequences.” A May 2026 hearing focused on the scope of the constitutional challenge, which the judge called “critically important.”22The Stanford Daily. Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Daily Lawsuit

The 17-State Admissions Data Lawsuit

In August 2025, Trump directed the Department of Education to expand the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System through a new survey called the Admissions and Consumer Transparency Supplement, requiring seven years of disaggregated data on applicants and enrollees, including race, sex, standardized test scores, GPAs, financial aid, and graduation rates.23McGuire Woods. 17 States Sue Trump Administration Over College Admissions Data Demands

On March 11, 2026, 17 states sued in Massachusetts federal court, arguing the Department exceeded its statutory authority and violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the Paperwork Reduction Act. On April 3, 2026, U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV granted a preliminary injunction, calling the 120-day implementation timeline “rushed and chaotic.” The injunction covers public universities in the plaintiff states, and several higher education associations, including the Association of American Universities, intervened and obtained similar relief.24Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse. Massachusetts v. Department of Education The case remains active with no reported appeal of the injunction as of mid-2026.25Association of American Universities. US District Court Issues Preliminary Injunction Against ACTS

The Fight Over Dismantling the Department of Education

On March 20, 2025, Trump signed an executive order directing Secretary of Education Linda McMahon to take steps to close the Department of Education and return authority to states, with the caveat that implementation must be “consistent with applicable law.”26The White House. Improving Education Outcomes by Empowering Parents, States, and Communities Because Congress established the Department in 1979, lawmakers and experts across parties have said actually closing it requires legislation.27National Conference of State Legislatures. What to Know About Trump’s Order to Close the Education Department

The Department nonetheless implemented a reduction in force in March 2025, cutting staff from more than 4,100 to fewer than 2,200. A coalition led by New York sued in New York v. McMahon, and on May 22, 2025, a Massachusetts federal judge issued a preliminary injunction blocking the mass layoffs, finding the executive branch was attempting to “effectively dismantle the Department without an authorizing statute” in violation of the separation of powers and the APA.28Oregon Department of Justice. Dismantling of Education Department, New York v. McMahon

The First Circuit denied a stay. On July 14, 2025, the Supreme Court granted the administration’s application for a stay, lifting the district court’s preliminary injunction while the case proceeds. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, dissented, arguing the majority’s decision allows the executive branch to “repeal statutes by firing all those necessary to carry them out.”29Cornell Law Institute. McMahon v. New York, No. 24A1203 The case is back in district court for further litigation.

The Early-Decision Antitrust Class Action

Separate from any government action, a class action filed August 8, 2025, accuses 32 elite colleges of using binding early-decision admissions to suppress competition and inflate tuition. D’Amico v. Consortium on Financing Higher Education was filed in U.S. District Court in Massachusetts by four current or former students at Wesleyan, Vassar, and Washington University in St. Louis.30Higher Ed Dive. 32 Colleges Accused of Using Early Decision to Drive Up Costs

Defendants include Amherst, Brown, Columbia, Cornell, Dartmouth, Duke, Emory, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Pomona, Rice, the University of Chicago, the University of Pennsylvania, and Vanderbilt, along with the Consortium on Financing Higher Education, the Common Application, and Scoir (which operates the Coalition App).31Cohen Milstein. Early Decision Antitrust Litigation

The complaint alleges a per se violation of the Sherman Act. Plaintiffs contend that while colleges present early decision as legally binding, it is actually an unenforceable “honor-bound” practice used to lock students in before they can compare financial aid offers, and that shared application platforms let schools identify and police students who apply early to more than one institution.32Cohen Milstein. Students File Landmark Lawsuit Alleging Elite Colleges Conspired to Present Early Decision as Binding, Inflate Tuition The suit seeks class certification, monetary damages, and an injunction against binding early-decision policies. The case is active.33Forbes. Lawsuit Accuses 32 Elite Colleges of Early Decision Admissions Conspiracy

Student Loan Litigation and the SAVE-to-RAP Transition

The Biden-era “Saving on a Valuable Education” plan has been terminated. After the Eighth Circuit enjoined the entire plan in February 2025 and the Trump administration stopped defending it, the Department of Education and Missouri reached a settlement in December 2025 formally ending the program. Over seven million enrolled borrowers must select a new repayment option.34U.S. Department of Education. Department of Education Announces Agreement With Missouri to End SAVE Plan

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, creates a replacement Repayment Assistance Plan, or RAP, taking effect by July 1, 2026. RAP sets monthly payments at one to ten percent of adjusted gross income, with a $50 reduction per dependent and a $10 minimum. Forgiveness comes after 30 years of repayment, longer than the 20 to 25 years under IBR and PAYE.35NPR. Student Loans Guide: Education Changes and Repayment Plan

The law also introduces a Tiered Standard Plan with terms of 10 to 25 years based on total debt. Legacy plans (ICR, PAYE, SAVE) will be fully eliminated by July 1, 2028, with remaining enrollees moved to RAP automatically. New borrowers after July 1, 2026, will be limited to the Tiered Standard Plan or RAP. Parent PLUS borrowers are not eligible for RAP and must use the Tiered Standard Plan.36NASFAA. Federal Student Aid Changes Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act

Other Active and Recent Cases

Texas Senate Bill 2972, the “Campus Protection Act,” took effect September 1, 2025, requiring public universities to restrict student speech between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. On October 14, 2025, U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra issued a preliminary injunction blocking the law, writing that “the First Amendment does not have a bedtime of 10 p.m.” He found the policy gave administrators excessive discretion to suppress particular religious or political activities.37Inside Higher Ed. Judge Halts UT’s Comprehensive Ban on Student Speech

On February 27, 2026, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth canceled Senior Service College Fellowship programs at 22 universities including Princeton, Columbia, MIT, Brown, Yale, and Harvard. The fellowship is small, with roughly 80 fellows per cycle, and undergraduate ROTC students and officers pursuing graduate studies independently are unaffected. No legal challenges to the directive have been reported.38CBS News. Hegseth Pentagon Cutting Ties With Top Universities

Hannibal-LaGrange University, a small Missouri Baptist school, sued the Department of Education in May 2025 over a 2024 regulation requiring program participation agreements to be signed by an entity with ownership power over the institution. The case was dismissed on January 16, 2026, after the Department issued new guidance the same day clarifying that the Missouri Baptist Convention is not required to provide financial guarantees for affiliated universities solely because it appoints their trustees.39WGEM. Hannibal-LaGrange University Settles Lawsuit With Department of Education

A 2024 class action by UCLA professor Lucina Uddin against the six largest for-profit academic publishers (Elsevier, Wolters Kluwer, Wiley, Sage, Taylor & Francis, and Springer Nature) alleged collusion to force unpaid peer review and single-journal submissions. In early February 2026, U.S. District Judge Hector Gonzalez dismissed the case, ruling the cited industry guidelines were “a collection of policies and guidelines concerning best practices” rather than evidence of a conspiracy, and declined to allow amendment.40Inside Higher Ed. Antitrust Lawsuit Against Academic Publishers Dismissed