How to Fund Schools Without Property Taxes: State and Federal Options

Funding schools without property taxes means replacing the largest single revenue stream in American public education with a combination of other sources, because no single alternative is big enough on its own. Local property taxes generate roughly $340 billion a year for schools and supply about 83 percent of all local school revenue.1National Center for Education Statistics. Public School Revenue Sources States that have meaningfully reduced their reliance on property taxes did so by raising statewide income and sales taxes, layering in lottery and gaming revenue, and leaning on targeted federal grants. Each of those sources solves part of the problem and creates a new one.

The Scale of What Has to Be Replaced

In fiscal year 2023, states contributed about $423 billion to K-12 education, local governments contributed roughly $403 billion, and the federal government provided approximately $120 billion.1National Center for Education Statistics. Public School Revenue Sources The overwhelming majority of the local share is property tax. That is why communities with lower property values usually generate less school revenue per student than wealthier ones, and why decades of state supreme court rulings have pushed legislatures to shift funding toward statewide sources.

Any serious plan to reduce property-tax dependence has to answer a specific dollar question: where does the replacement money come from, and can it hold up when the economy turns?

State Income Taxes

State income taxes are the largest non-property-tax revenue stream for public education in most states. Collections from individuals and, in many states, corporations flow into a general fund or a dedicated education fund and are then distributed to districts. Because higher earners pay more under a progressive rate structure, income taxes spread the cost of education more broadly than property taxes, which fall only on property owners and reflect real estate values rather than a household’s actual ability to pay.

The most ambitious approach is what policy analysts call a “tax swap.” A handful of states have sharply cut local school property-tax rates and replaced the lost revenue with higher statewide income or sales taxes. One well-documented example cut local school operating millage rates by more than 75 percent, raised the state’s share of K-12 funding from about 29 percent to nearly 78 percent, and narrowed the spending gap between the highest- and lowest-revenue districts from roughly 3-to-1 to less than 2-to-1 within a decade. The state’s sales and income tax burdens rose above national averages as a result. Per-pupil spending at the lowest-funded districts rose significantly faster than inflation.

Not every state can copy that outcome. States without an income tax rely more heavily on sales taxes or extraction-based revenue, and the political appetite for raising statewide taxes to offset local property-tax cuts varies. What the tax-swap experience does show is that large-scale restructuring is possible when a state actually commits to replacing the revenue rather than cutting property taxes and hoping the gap closes on its own.

State Sales Taxes

Sales taxes broaden the funding base beyond property owners, since anyone who buys taxable goods and services contributes. Some states earmark a specific share of sales-tax collections for education; others route the money into a general fund that supports schools alongside other state services. Either way, the result is a statewide pool distributed through funding formulas.

Two problems come with sales taxes as a school revenue source. They are regressive: lower-income families spend a larger share of their income on taxable goods, so a state that replaces property taxes with sales taxes may solve one equity problem while creating another. And sales-tax revenue is volatile. Consumer spending drops sharply during recessions, and states that fund schools primarily through income and sales taxes tend to experience deeper education budget cuts during downturns than states with heavier property-tax reliance, because property assessments adjust slowly even when market values fall.

That volatility matters for districts with fixed obligations like teacher salaries and building maintenance. States that lean on sales taxes for schools often need larger reserve funds to avoid lurching between surplus and austerity every business cycle.

Lotteries, Sports Betting, and Cannabis Revenue

Roughly 30 states direct some or all of their lottery proceeds toward education. The appeal is that lottery revenue does not require raising tax rates. In practice, after prize payouts and administrative costs, public schools often receive less than a quarter of every dollar spent on tickets.2EdBuild. Lotteries as School Funding: The Game Is Rigged And because state legislatures sometimes cut general-fund appropriations by roughly the amount lottery revenue brings in, the net effect on school budgets can be smaller than headline numbers suggest.

Sports betting is a newer entrant. As more states legalize and tax sports wagering, a growing number are earmarking a portion of the tax revenue for education or early childhood programs. Total sports-betting tax revenue across all states is still a small fraction of state budgets. At least four states with legalized recreational cannabis direct a share of excise-tax revenue to K-12 education, funding school construction and general operating budgets.

None of these sources comes close to replacing property taxes. They work best as one piece of a diversified revenue strategy, filling gaps or paying for specific priorities like school construction.

Corporate and Severance Taxes

Corporate income taxes, franchise taxes, and other business levies feed the state general funds that support public schools. These revenues are rarely earmarked for education, but they expand the pot available for legislative appropriation. The catch is that states frequently grant tax abatements and incentives to attract businesses, and those deals erode the school funding base. State and local governments collectively spend tens of billions of dollars annually on business tax incentives, with property-tax abatements alone accounting for an estimated $12 billion per year in the most recent comprehensive national data. Because property taxes are the primary local source for schools, those abatements often translate directly into less money for classrooms.

Severance taxes, levied on the extraction of oil, natural gas, and minerals, provide a substantial revenue stream in resource-rich states. In a few states, severance taxes account for 3 to 14 percent of all state and local general revenue, and portions flow to education either through direct earmarks or general-fund allocations.3Tax Policy Center. How Do State and Local Severance Taxes Work? The limitation is obvious. Only states with significant extractive industries can lean on this revenue, and commodity price swings make it unpredictable year to year.

Federal Funding Programs

Federal dollars are the smallest share of school funding, and they are not designed to replace local revenue wholesale. They flow through formula grants targeted to specific student populations and needs.

Title I

Title I, Part A is the largest federal K-12 education program. It provides formula grants to districts with high numbers or percentages of students from low-income families, with the goal of closing achievement gaps. In fiscal year 2024, Title I, Part A received approximately $18.4 billion in appropriations.4U.S. Department of Education. Title I, Part A: Improving Basic Programs Operated by Local Educational Agencies

IDEA

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act guarantees students with disabilities a free appropriate public education and helps states cover the cost of special education and related services.5U.S. Department of Education. State Formula Grants – Individuals with Disabilities Education Act IDEA Part B state grants totaled roughly $14.6 billion in fiscal year 2025.6U.S. Congress. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), Part B Even at that level, federal IDEA funding covers only a fraction of what districts actually spend on special education. The federal government has never come close to its original promise of covering 40 percent of the additional cost.

Impact Aid

Impact Aid compensates districts that contain significant amounts of nontaxable federal land, such as military bases, tribal reservations, or national parks. Because those properties generate no local property-tax revenue, nearby districts can face substantial funding shortfalls. To qualify under the basic federal-property provisions, a district must show that eligible federal land accounts for at least 10 percent of the assessed value of all real property in the district.7eCFR. Part 222 Impact Aid Programs In fiscal year 2025, the program received approximately $1.47 billion in appropriations, meaningful for the roughly 1,100 districts that rely on it but a small slice of overall federal education spending.

Other Programs and the Current Outlook

Title IV, Part A provides flexible block grants that districts can use for well-rounded education initiatives, school safety, and instructional technology.8U.S. Department of Education. Student Support and Academic Enrichment Program (Title IV, Part A) Other federal streams cover migrant education, English-language acquisition, and teacher development.

Federal education funding faces significant uncertainty going into fiscal year 2026. The administration’s FY2026 budget proposal requests roughly $12 billion in cuts to education spending, including consolidating 18 K-12 grant programs into a single block grant funded at approximately 70 percent less than the combined current level. A House subcommittee bill proposed funding Title I, Part A at $14.6 billion for FY2026, a cut of nearly $3.8 billion from FY2025 levels. Separately, the administration has already rescinded or frozen billions of dollars in previously approved K-12 funding during FY2025. Districts that depend on federal grants for supplemental staffing, tutoring, or special education services face real planning challenges when funding levels are in flux.

The Trade-Offs of Moving Away From Property Taxes

Every alternative solves some problems and creates others. Property taxes are unpopular, but they have a feature other taxes lack: stability. Assessments change slowly, so school budgets do not collapse overnight when the economy turns. States that shifted school funding to income and sales taxes generally saw deeper education cuts during the Great Recession than states that kept more property-tax funding, because paychecks and consumer spending fell faster than property values.

Equity is the strongest argument for diversifying away from property taxes. When school funding tracks local real estate wealth, children in low-value communities receive less, and that gap tends to compound over time through lower teacher salaries, fewer course offerings, and deferred maintenance. State-level revenue sources, especially progressive income taxes, can redistribute resources toward districts that need them most. The evidence from states that executed large-scale tax swaps suggests the equity gains are real and durable, even if the replacement taxes bring their own political headaches.

Constitutional constraints matter too. Every state constitution contains an education clause, and courts have interpreted these clauses to require either adequacy, equity, or both. States that cut property taxes without fully replacing the revenue risk lawsuits arguing that school funding falls below constitutional minimums. States that increase their centralized share of funding gain more control over how dollars are distributed, which makes it easier to satisfy judicial mandates for equity.

What a Workable Mix Looks Like

For most states, the realistic path is not eliminating property taxes from school funding entirely. It is reducing dependence on them by building a more diversified revenue base. Income taxes do the heaviest lifting, sales taxes broaden the base, lottery and gaming revenue fill specific priorities, corporate and severance taxes contribute where the economy allows, and federal grants cover targeted populations. States that have made the biggest strides toward equity did so by raising statewide taxes to offset property-tax cuts, designing funding formulas that direct more dollars to higher-need students, and maintaining reserves large enough to ride out recessions without gutting school budgets.